top of page
08_john_atkinson_grimshaw_edited (1).jpg




Literary Essays on Gothic Horror, Ghost Stories & Weird Fiction

from  Mary  Shelley  to  M.  R.  James —

by M. Grant Kellermeyer

S U B S C R I B E:

Our sincerest thanks for your subscription.

We will be haunting your inbox soon...

E. Nesbit's The Shadow: A Two-Minute Summary and Analysis

“The Shadow” is Nesbit’s worthiest bid for the literary ghost story – that rare genre of powerful, elegant supernaturalism that thunders in your ears after you read it, haunts you intermittently for days, and disturbs some dark and quiet spot of your soul. Henry James (“The Jolly Corner,” “The Real, Right Thing,” “The Ghostly Rental”), Edith Wharton (“The Eyes,” “The Lady’s Maid’s Bell”), Willa Cather (“Consequences”), and Charles Dickens (“The Signal-Man,” “To Be Read at Dusk”) were masters of this unusual style: a ghost story that was actually not at all about supernatural mythologies, spooky sights, or Gothic atmosphere, but rather one that was deeply concerned with the condition of the human soul.

In “The Real, Right Thing” a man begins to write a biography of his dead friend until his ghost warns him away from it for unknown reasons. In “The Eyes” a man sees a ghostly set of eyes as a youth and doesn’t realize until his old age that they were his own – wrinkled and reddened by a life of negligent greed. In “The Signal-Man” a railway worker is haunted by a vision that warns him of disasters with no hope of stopping them, filling his heart with guilt and anxiety.

These smartly written stories are far more effective at disturbing us than scaring us, but they last in our memories far longer than tales of blood and vampires. “Man-Size in Marble” and “John Charrington’s Wedding” are unquestionable classics – masterpieces – of supernatural fiction, but they are still more genre pieces than literary in quality. Nesbit has achieved such philosophical heights in three other stories: “The House of Silence,” “The Violet Car,” and “Uncle Abraham’s Romance.” All four of these tales evoke that same kind of realism, moral disturbance, and plot ambiguity that are the trademark of the literary ghost story, and have a very discernable kinship to the ghost stories of James, Wharton, and Dickens. An elegant and puzzling tale, Nesbit frames it at that most ghostly setting – a Christmas party in an old house – and warns us in advance: it is a mystery to be pondered. So it is.


“This is not an artistically rounded-off ghost story, and nothing is explained in it, and there seems to be no reason why any of it should have happened. But that is no reason why it should not be told. You must have noticed that all the real ghost stories you have ever come close to, are like this in these respects – no explanation, no logical coherence…” These are the philosophical opening words of a story told by a woman looking back on a strange, sad episode from her girlhood.

“There were three of us and another,” she recalls about a group of friends attending a country Christmas party years ago. The fourth girl – “the other” – had fainted after a raucous night of dancing at a grand, old house, and had been tucked away to bed. As the night wanes, the partiers regroup to their sleeping quarters (worse for drink, the young men sleep on sofas, floors, and the dining room table while the girls cluster in the antique guest rooms) and settle in for the night. The girls gossip about the boys, giggle, and joke, but as the winter evening deepens and darkens – “broken only by the whisper of the wind in the cedar branches, and the scraping of their harsh fingers against our windowpanes” – the mood becomes decidedly spookier.

The girls call to mind a host of famous ghost stories (including Amelia B. Edwards’ “The Phantom Coach,” Walter Scott’s “The Tapestried Chamber,” Wilkie Collins’ “A Horribly Strange Bed,” and Rhoda Broughton’s “Nothing But the Truth”), and are terribly startled by a sudden tap on the door. It’s only Miss Eastwich – the narrator’s aunt’s housekeeper – whom the girls consider utterly plain, boring, and unromantic.

She was drawn to the room out of concern, seeing the lights flickering under the door at such a late hour. It is clear to the narrator – who notices her glance at the door to the room where the fainted girl is sleeping – that she is actually worried that a fit of exhaustion might have turned into something more serious. Silent, serious, and stoic, Eastwich meekly accepts the chattering girls’ invitation to join their story telling session and have some cocoa by the snapping fire. The youngest girl – an impetuous heiress who doesn’t know the implacable, machine-like Eastwich like the narrator does – insists on hearing a ghost story (to the narrator’s horror).

But the grim, middle-aged woman is touched by their invitation – she is given the coziest chair, the narrator’s shawl, and a cup of cocoa – and warms her bony face and hands in the blaze. The youngest girl again insists on hearing Eastwich’s best ghost story, saying that although none of them believe in ghost stories, they love the pastime – even if all the stories they hear tend to be second-hand and “artistically rounded off” in a tidy, mystery-ending manner. Eastwich, who grimly claims to have a genuine-if-strange first-hand account of a haunting, stares pensively into the fire and mutters something about not being able to do any harm with her story since all the girls are over twenty and not likely to frighten...


Twenty years ago, she says, she had two friends whom she loved more than anything in the world – a young woman and her fiancée – and in the sadness of her voice, the narrator infers that the love may have been rather complicated. After their marriage Eastwich saw less and less of them, but two years later she received a letter from the husband asking her to visit: his wife was very ill and needed looking after (we will later learn that the “illness” is a very troubled pregnancy).

They lived in a new house with a cheerful façade but a deeply gloomy atmosphere. When Eastwich arrives the husband thanks her and asks her to “forgive the past” (a comment which mystifies the youngest girl, to the narrator’s annoyance) and she does. Mabel, the wife, is weak and excitable from her pregnancy, and so she often leaves her friend and husband alone when she goes to bed early. The two spend their nights gazing worriedly into the fireplace.

One night he tells her that he finds the house peculiar, and that if it were not brand new, he would consider it haunted. She asks if he has seen anything, and he replies “no, not yet… There’s a sort of a feeling … I’ve seen nothing and heard nothing, but I’ve been so near to seeing and hearing, just near, that’s all. And something follows me about – only when I turn round, there’s never anything, only my shadow…” He says that he hopes Eastwich – whom he calls Margaret – could help him, and asks if she believes in curses, and whether he thinks anyone he may have wronged in the past could have put a curse on him. He wonders aloud if such a person could forgive him and break the curse, and Margaret assures him that they could.

Margaret urges him to take Mabel away, but Mabel has spent so much time preparing the house for the baby that he worries what a move would do to her. Margaret continues listening to his solemn musings, and as if his worrisome spirit were contagious, she too begins to sense a presence – even in broad daylight, and particularly on the stairs and passage ways. Sometimes, as she climbs the stairs, she has to bite her lip to keep from sprinting in terror. One night she is alone in the kitchen heating up milk for Mabel and begins to suspect that the days of “almost seeing” are quickly progressing into materialization. Indeed, she sees something crouching in a cupboard and calls Mabel’s name, but realizes that it is something vague and inhuman: an inky, disembodied shadow which slithers away into the darkness, causing Margaret to scream.

When she sees the husband he agrees that the force is emanating from the cupboard. They both continue to see “something that would crouch and sink, and lie like a black pool, and then slowly draw itself into the shadow that was nearest.” Often, they note, the Shadow seems to come from their own, natural shadows. One morning she actually hears the Shadow sigh (an experience far worse than seeing it), and she wonders how she has been able to stand being in the house before remembering that her love for Mabel and her husband has left her no choice.

Then the baby is born and some of the tension leaves them: Mabel is still unwell, but they plan to take her to the sea once she recuperates. But one night after discussing this, Margaret listens at their bedroom door, then turns around to see the Shadow towering in the gloom, right before plunging to the floor and sucking its way under the door… Afraid, Margaret bursts in to find Mabel sleeping peacefully beside the baby. Relieved, she prays to herself that Mabel would never know about the terrors she has experienced with Mabel’s husband. Eastwich pauses here and bitterly notes that her prayer was answered: Mabel never woke up.

At the funeral, Margaret and the widower stand over the coffin and hold hands. She begins to lead him away, but a sigh – the sigh of the Shadow – freezes their blood. Between them and the coffin they see It pooling, then – having been sighted – it bolts for the nearest shadow: the one under Mabel’s elevated casket. Margaret leaves the next day and Mabel’s mother-in-law (a women who never liked Margaret) takes her place. The next time she saw him, the black thing crouching between him was his second wife mourning over his own casket, dressed in widow’s weeds…


The girls are stunned with sadness. Eastwich mutters to herself that it isn’t a very pleasant story which doesn’t lead anywhere. She had never told it to anyone before, and wonders if the only reason she felt like sharing it was the emotion she felt at seeing Mabel’s daughter again, and her gaze flows to the fainted girl’s room. “Mabel’s baby?” the girls ask, “Yes,” she responds, “and exactly like Mabel, only with his eyes.” The youngest girl, mellowed by the story, takes Eastwich’s cold hands and begins stroking them.

Suddenly, Eastwich bolts upright and gasps, eyes bulging at the dark corner by the fainted girl’s door: something unseen is standing there, and – following her gaze – the narrator tracks it as it sinks, widens, and glides beneath the door. The girls are unsure if they’ve seen anything, but they all hear a quivering sigh fill the room, and they bolt to the girl’s bedside – the narrator holding a guttering candle aloft and the youngest wrapping her arms protectively around Eastwich (the narrator notes that they been enveloping her ever since, and that the youngest eventually hired Eastwich as her housekeeper).

In the morning the doctor determines that the cause of death was a heart disease which she had inherited from Mabel, her mother. The narrator sadly disagrees: “But I have sometimes wondered whether she may not have inherited something from her father. I had never been able to forget the look on her dead face…”